Why did Abdul El-Sayed draw cheers at a church service he didn’t attend? Make It Plain host Mark Thompson breaks down Haley Stevens’s endorsement of Mike Rogers.
PLEASE BECOME A PAID SUBSCRIBER TODAY
We make our newsletters and videos free because everyone deserves the truth, regardless of their ability to pay. To counter the lies of the billionaire and corporate media, we must reach as many Americans as possible. We don’t need unlimited funds, but we rely entirely on small-dollar grassroots support to keep going. Please become a paid subscriber today so we can keep flooding the zone with the truth. We can’t do this without you.
Summary
Mark Thompson heard something at Detroit’s Perfecting Church that the election coverage could easily miss. Rep. Haley Stevens showed up with Republican Senate candidate Mike Rogers, but by Thompson’s account, the congregation cheered louder for the Democrat who wasn’t there. On Politics Done Right, the Make It Plain host explained why that moment matters to the Michigan voters who chose Abdul El-Sayed in the first place.
- Stevens broke a public commitment. After losing the Democratic primary to El-Sayed and pledging to support him, she endorsed Rogers two days before Election Day.
- Thompson challenged the party’s double standard. Progressives routinely hear that they owe the nominee their support. He asked why some establishment Democrats take so long to honor the same obligation when a progressive wins.
- The congregation had a voice of its own. Thompson said Bishop Marvin Winans acknowledged both candidates and remarked on the applause for the absent El-Sayed. The photograph captured who stood beside Rogers. It couldn’t capture whom the congregation cheered.
-
Thompson saw an opening for solidarity. In his reading, the appearance could bring Black and Arab American Michiganders closer by giving both communities a reason to reject politicians who presume to speak for them.
-
He also placed obligations on the winners. Thompson urged voters to organize after the election for voting rights, reproductive freedom, immigrant protections, and civilian oversight of police, including when Democrats hold office.
Thompson’s challenge runs in both directions. Candidates who ask for a community’s loyalty owe it something in return, and the people who put them in office have every right to collect.
Premium Content (Complimentary)
Haley Stevens broke her word. Mark Thompson heard Detroit’s answer.
When Haley Stevens walked into Detroit’s Perfecting Church beside Mike Rogers, the Republican got the picture any campaign would want two days before an election. A Democratic member of Congress, the woman who had run against Abdul El-Sayed in the primary, had come to worship alongside his Republican opponent. Then came the part a photograph couldn’t show. As Mark Thompson recounted on Politics Done Right, Bishop Marvin Winans mentioned El-Sayed, heard the congregation respond, and observed that the absent Democrat got the louder cheer. Somebody should ask those churchgoers what they thought of Sunday’s service. They seem to have had plenty to say.
Stevens made a promise after the primary. She endorsed the man who defeated her. On November 1, she reversed herself and endorsed Rogers. Donald Trump promptly invited her into the Republican Party. By Monday, the Michigan Democratic Party had expelled her, and El-Sayed was at Eastern Michigan University talking to students about turning out. Those details settle one question. Whatever Stevens hoped to accomplish, the immediate political beneficiary understood exactly what she had given him. Trump publicly thanked her in the currency he had available: a welcome into his party.
Stevens deserves an examination of her stated reason. She raised concerns about antisemitism, criticized El-Sayed’s appearances with streamer Hasan Piker and objected to an outside group’s ad linking U.S. support for Israel to grocery prices. One fact matters here. On Saturday, El-Sayed explicitly rejected the ad’s message. Stevens welcomed his remarks. On Sunday, she still endorsed his Republican opponent. Voters can take antisemitism seriously and still ask what, exactly, electing Mike Rogers would do to remedy the conduct she described. Stevens owed them an answer, particularly after asking them to trust her judgment the first time.
Thompson recognized a familiar arrangement. When a progressive loses a primary, party leaders expect the volunteers who knocked doors in the rain to knock those same doors for the winner. Those volunteers swallow real disagreements because a Senate seat carries consequences. Michigan’s progressive voters won their primary. Why should the obligation they would have honored in defeat suddenly become optional for the congresswoman they defeated? The state party answered for itself by expelling Stevens. Democratic leaders elsewhere can answer by committing organizers, money, and their own reputations when a progressive earns the nomination.
Consider what got crowded out of the coverage. El-Sayed campaigns on Medicare for All and affordable housing. A Michigan worker weighing a job change has good reason to care whether the family’s health insurance goes with the job. A renter whose next raise disappears into the next lease has good reason to ask who profits from the shortage. Neither gets an answer from a weekend of coverage about whom Stevens stood beside. Both have a stake in whether the next senator challenges the private interests that make a living off those insecurities.
Thompson saved his toughest demand for the people most likely to agree with him. Keep showing up after the votes come in. Ask the senator what happened to voting-rights legislation. Ask the school board who decides which books children can read. Show up when city officials decide whether residents can meaningfully investigate police misconduct. A congregation’s applause lasts a few seconds. The habit behind it, people making up their own minds and letting powerful people hear the answer, can last well beyond Election Day.
